answer this question

Twilight Series Question

What parts of Eclipse book did you want in the movie that wasn't in the movie???

Example. They changed it at the end where edward says "dont be scared" to bella when he ripped of victoia's head off and in the book bella didnt cut herself!!!

 Crazy_4_Twinas posted over a year ago
next question »

Twilight Series Answers

mandapanda said:
I kind of wanted Edward to be more composed like he always is. For example, in the book, when he's angry, he plainly, calmly threatens. It makes it more menacing and I wish we saw some of that in the movie.

I wish they showed more of Bella wanting Edward and trying to have sex with him. It's pivotal because it sets up for their "compromise". She's always thinking about it and wants him. In the movie, it just seemed like a one time thing.

I wish they showed the Quil imprinting on Claire speech. It would set up for Breaking Dawn and prepare people. First, because people could interpret the imprinting a different way. Second, because people still refer to Jacob as a pedo and that's not going to change if they don't establish that. Which, they lost their chance in Eclipse. Instead, they made it seem like a love thing. "It's not gravity that holds you to the earth, it's her." Please... try saying that to justify your actions when he imprints on Nessie and he'll be castrated.

I wish there were more Edward and Bella moments from the book. Not even big scenes, just subtle things. In the movie, they were lovey dovey I guess, but not nearly as much in the book and I really wish we could have seen more of that.

I wanted them to show Jacob as how he is in the book. Not always so remorseful like Taylor plays him or how the character is written in the script. Jacob isn't sorry after he does things until Bella guilts him. He wasn't sorry when he kissed her for the first time, not at first anyways. I wanted them to show Jacob's cockiness and rudeness towards Edward. I wanted them to show Edward being mentally tortured by Jacob's memories of Bella in New Moon. It would add more emotion and people will at least understand why Edward hates himself.

Those were some pivotal things that I thought should have been in the movie. Other little moments would have been nice, but these certain things that I mentioned would have established the characters and their relationships a whole lot better.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
yeahh it would be better
Crazy_4_Twinas posted over a year ago
next question »